1. Thank youThe algorithm is not perfect but it allows you to be creative and play without worrying about replicating it later! The editing feature needs to be improved, I cant even figure out how to add a note where one does not exist (and some were not present in the output) but I am a huge fan! I was wishing something existed that allowed real instruments to be transcribed into sheet music just the other day and Voila! Melody scanner to the rescue!Oh, boy this needs work.
2. I have held off on paying for premium, only because I'm always broke, but it it totally feels like a perfect learning tool to combine with Fender Play, or Yousician, and if you like Melody Scanner, you should definately also try Fretboard Learn, HumOn, and maybe try Maestro.I got this app hoping it could listen to a song and give me the melody notes to help learn.
3. There was one melody that I wanted to play so badly on the piano and I couldn't find the exact one, but melody scanner came to the rescue and transcribed it almost perfectly.
4. Y'all can complain about $5 all you want, I'm just thrilled to get help on songs I've listened to and loved for years.Best Transcriber I have seen, .. PERIOD! I've tried numerous web based Transcriber's AND different App's over the last 5 years & this is THE Very best.
5. The time limit being only one minute is definitely not helpful at all, especially when I want to have my band play a song play a three and a half minute song.
6. It's definitely not perfect and some songs are not transcribed well, however melody scanner has helped me quite a few times.
7. I love this app 'cause I wrote so many songs when I was in high school but I never wrote down anything down, so the only way I can see how to play them is if I had an apple device which I don't have but I saved a lot of them to YouTube so I can always listen to them.
8. A large problem I found with my first scan was that the music was transcribed poorly when a video only had little noise.
9. The melody and notes were mostly correct but the length the notes were held for were all kinds of messed up.
10. I just wish that it could detect the notes and chords better, if this problem was solved then you got an app that can write any song into scores/tabs.
11. The only mode that will work well is the one where you plug in a midi device but at that point u could record midi with any decent dawThis is like Christmas.